The first meeting of a busy season in Johannisthal
Waiting for flights in one of the airfield cafés. (1)
The skids that curve up to join the front framework and the big
ailerons identify Amerigo's Sommer. (2)
Jeannin preparing for a flight in his first machine. This was a
Farman built under license by Aviatik in Mülhausen. It had
ailerons only on the top wings and was equipped with a 55 hp Argus
inline four-cylinder engine. (1)
Von Gorrissen in flight. Except for the landing gear the Euler was
very similar to a Voisin. (1)
A couple of nurses in front of the grandstand. (3)
Baron de Caters and Ellery von Gorrissen, together with Elisabeth
Woerner, who flew with de Caters on the morning of Saturday 14 May.
(4)
Thorup's Blériot being salvaged after his crash into a tree.
This was only the first of four accidents on Saturday 14 May. (1)
The sad remains of Thelen's #13 Wright after his crash. The
ground hardly looks like an ideal landing field. (1)
De Caters in his Voisin passing smartly over the first line of the
"Höhenkurven-Preis" course... (1)
...and below the second, before passing over the third. With the
lines spaced only 40 metres apart this was certainly no easy test.
(1)
The wreckage after Engelhard's failed attempt to negotiate the
"Höhenkurven-Preis" course. (1)
Jeannin in his reserve machine. This was an original French Farman,
recognizable by the ailerons on the lower wings. (3)
The reserve machine didn't last long. Here it is, inverted,
after Jeannin's second crash. (1)
Frey flying above de Caters' Voisin. (1)
An official checking the results, which were marked on a strip of
paper by electromagnetically operated pens, one line for each
machine. Each pylon was equipped with a switchboard, where a pylon
judge signalled the passing of the different machines by pushing
buttons. This for its time very advanced equipment was installed
already before the 1909 meeting. (1)
During the winter the Berlin Johannisthal airfield, the centre of
German aviation, had been financially reorganized, with the old
managing society "Deutsche Flugplatz-Gesellschaft" being
replaced by the "Flug- und Sportplatz-Gesellschaft
Berlin-Johannisthal" and fresh capital brought in. Work had
started on expanding the hangars and other installations in the
previously unexploited north-western parts of the field, and on realigning
and extending the race course and spectator areas, but these works were
not completed in time for the first of the three aviation meetings
planned for 1910.
At many early meetings big prizes were offered to the pilots that
amassed the highest total flying time. When the first fascination of
seeing aeroplanes fly at all had worn off, the sight of machines flying
for hours at safe speeds and safe low altitudes didn't appeal so
much to the spectators. The organizers of the Berlin spring meeting
therefore tried to introduce more crowd-pleasing competitions that
would reward skilled pilots and manoeuvrable planes. These included a
precision landing contest, a contest for the smallest circle flown, a
contest for the longest glide and the "Höhenkurven-Preis",
offered for the pilot who could alternately fly above and below wires
strung ten meters above the ground as close as possible to each other.
They also tried to encourage flights early in the day, rather than as
late as possible when the conditions were usually more favourable, by
offering prizes ("Frühpreisen") for the first two flights of
each day and offering bonus minutes to pilots who made their efforts
for endurance contest earlier in the afternoons.
The summer and autumn meetings of the 1910 Berlin season were only open
to German flyers, but the spring meeting was international. However,
the losses incurred by the previous year's meeting, and the fact
that there wasn't as much sponsorship money available in Germany as
in France and other countries, restricted the prize fund to 75,000
Mark, which didn't attract the foreign top names. The most
accomplished foreigner was Baron Pierre de Caters, who entered one of
his Voisins. The other participants were Germans and foreign
novices:
- Stefano Amerigo (Italy), Sommer
- Adolf Behrend (Germany), Schultze-Herfort
- Pierre de Caters (Belgium), Voisin
- Paul Engelhard (Germany), Wright
- Alfred Frey (Germany), Farman
- Hans Grade (Germany), Grade
- Ellery von Gorrissen (Germany), Euler
- Emil Jeannin (Germany), Aviatik/Farman
- Fridolin Keidel (Germany), Wright
- Robert Svendsen (Denmark), Voisin
- Robert Thelen (Germany), Wright
- Knud Thorup (Denmark), Blériot
However, the Wright flyers, particularly
Korvettenkapitän
Engelhard, were accomplished pilots, as were Frey and Jeannin, who were
both trained at the Farman school in Mourmelon. Grade, perhaps the most
famous of the German pilots, didn't turn up at the beginning of the
meeting and it was only announced at a very late stage that he
wouldn't participate.
Tuesday 10 May
The first day of the meeting dawned with miserable weather. It rained
persistently and the wind was strong and quite gusty. The rain stopped
around noon and the wind calmed down somewhat, but at three
o'clock, when the flying was supposed to begin on all days, the
crowds were small and the pilots stood hesitating outside their
hangars. The wind was still between 6 and 8 m/s and it seemed that
nobody wanted to go for the "Frühpreis", offered for the
first three-lap flights between three and four o'clock. Engelhard
broke the deadlock by firing up his Wright. He took off, but was forced
down almost immediately by the wind. Despite this, Jeannin and Keidel
were obviously encouraged and took off, but both had to give up after
one and a half and two minutes respectively. The disappointed
spectators withdrew to the restaurants, not knowing whether to stay or
go home.
Around four o'clock Major von Tschudi of the race committee
announced that due to the inclement weather there would exceptionally
be a second window for the "Frühpreis" between five and six
o'clock. Engelhard was again first, and after a careful take-off
won the first prize with a flight of 8:40.2, flying very low and almost
skimming the ground. Jeannin was next to try and quickly rose to a
height of 20 meters, but after the first lap his right aileron failed
and forced him to land. Keidel was third, around a quarter of an hour
later, but at a turn on the north side of the course he lost altitude
and hit the ground. The lower wings and the rudders of his Wright were
badly damaged, but Keidel escaped without injury. After the accident
there was no more flying.
Wednesday 11 May
The weather was sunny and warm, but the winds were even stronger than
the day before, increasing from 10 m/s in the morning to 14 m/s in the
evening. No flying was possible. The management decided to give the
money back to those who had bought tickets, except those who had hangar
passes, since it was considered that they had at least got some value
for their money by being able to see the machines from close.
Thursday 12 May
The third day of the meeting was sunny and hot, almost too hot
according to some, but still very windy. The good weather attracted big
crowds to the airfield, but winds of 7-8 m/s made flights impossible
until 16:22, when the red flag was finally hoisted. Engelhard was again
first to fly. He took off at 16:41 and won the first
"Frühpreis", covering the three laps in 8:38 at a height or
around 3 metres. Jeannin in his Aviatik licence-built Farman was next,
winning the second prize with a flight of 8:28 at a height of 10-15
metres nine minutes later. Because of the unclaimed prizes of the
previous days the organizers had put up two extra first flight prizes
of 300 and 200 Mark. When Frey took off at 17:06 and flew several laps
at high altitude everybody believed that he was going for the third
prize, but to the consternation of spectators and officials he kept
making turns inside the pylons. When asked for the reason after
landing, he replied that such low sums were not worth competing for.
The wind calmed down more and more, and Amerigo, von Gorrissen, Thelen,
Svendsen, Behrend and Thorup brought out their machines from their
hangars. Immediately before six o'clock Engelhard made a flight for
the passenger prize, but had to give up after trying in vain for ten
minutes to get off the ground. Von Gorrissen, Thelen and Frey took off
soon after six, but Thelen's engine didn't sound right and they
had only been in the air for minutes when a big black cloud and a heavy
rain shower passed. The others landed and only von Gorrissen continued,
but he too had to give up after eleven minutes. During the rain shower
an approaching airship could be seen. It was the little sports airship
"Parseval VI", and it was soon flying stationary over the
middle of the airfield.
When the rain finished six planes were in the air, circling the airship
and trying for different prizes, a spectacular sight! Frey was
particularly celebrated after a 20-minute flight at altitudes over 150
meters, leaving the airfield and flying southwards over neighbouring
Rudow. Only two of the pilots didn't fly during the beautiful
evening: Keidel, whose machine was still being repaired, and de Caters,
who had brought a brand-new Voisin and wanted to test it before making
any competitive flights.
Friday 13 May
The good weather continued into the morning and de Caters finally got
the chance to test his new machine. He flew several laps and afterwards
he made two passenger flights, first with one of his mechanics and then
with bicycle champion Thaddeus Robl, who had himself started piloting
and would crash to his death, becoming the first victim of German
aviation, only a little more than a month later. Von Gorrissen also
made several flights during the morning, one of them with a passenger.
Around noon clouds started to gather and around three o'clock there
were a couple of thunderstorms, accompanied by heavy rain showers that
left lots of standing water on the airfield. The rain stopped around
four o'clock and at 16:49, when the field had dried up, Jeannin was
first in the air and claimed the first "Frühpreis". Engelhard
was second, four minutes later, but his flight didn't count, since
he didn't land afterwards but continued flying in order to go for
the "Dauerpreis", the endurance prize. Amerigo then failed to
leave the ground, and Thelen was third.
Then started a very busy series of flights for the totalisation prize
and the "Dauerpreis", and most of the time there were three
or four machines in the air. De Caters made four flights totalling 50
minutes, despite not being completely pleased with the way his new
machine handled. Behrend with difficulty made two flights, totalling 13
minutes. Svendsen made a flight of nine minutes before touching the
ground and breaking a couple of struts on his Voisin. Frey made two
flights, totalling 41 minutes, one of them with one of his mechanics as
passenger. Both Thorup and Amerigo had problems and failed to make more
than short hops, despite trying several times. Thelen flew 23 minutes
and von Gorrissen 14 minutes.
Two pilots still kept flying in the by now calm weather, Engelhard and
Jeannin. At 19:14 a strut came loose from its fittings and forced
Engelhard to land after being in the air for 2 h 12:15, a new
German endurance record. He couldn't enjoy the record for long
though, because Jeannin kept flying until the cannon was fired to
announce the end of the day's flights and landed at 19:50. His time
of 2 h 39:25 took back the record - it was he who had held the
record before Engelhard beat it.
Saturday 14 May
The weather was good and again de Caters started the day's flying,
taking Elisabeth Woerner, the wife of the director of the Frankfurt
"Deutsche Fluggesellschaft" for a flight. He then went on to
take the first "Frühpreis" by taking off only two minutes
after the window opened at three o'clock, followed by von Gorrissen
and Jeannin.
While this went on, the day's drama started - and there would be
lots of it. Thorup made a good take-off and flew along the start/finish
straight, but at the end of it his machine swerved, either because the
light Blériot was caught in the wash from other planes or because of
rudder failure. It flew into a line of trees, where it was left
hanging. Thorup managed to jump out and escaped without injury, but his
machine was out of action for the rest of the meeting.
Jeannin took off for a long flight at 15:15, followed by Engelhard who
flew some laps with a passenger. Then Svendsen, von Gorrissen, Thelen,
Frey and de Caters all made short flights of some minutes. Thelen's
flight ended with a violent crash in front of the main grandstand when
his Wright was caught in turbulence and pitched into the ground at
almost full speed. Despite crashing from only three or four metres the
machine was completely destroyed, only the engine was salvageable.
Thelen miraculously escaped injuries and could work his way out of the
wreckage.
Jeannin landed after being in the air for 1 h 23:06.6, the longest
flight of the day, and then there was a long break until 17:23, when de
Caters made his efforts for the "Höhenkurven-Preis". He
smartly finished the test, first with the lines at 50 metres from each
other, then 40 metres. At 18:19 Engelhard tried. He easily flew below
the first line, but when he was about to pass the second he was too far
to the right and the wings hit the pole and the machine crashed to the
ground. Engelhard was pulled from the wreckage with blood running over
his face. He had a deep cut over the left eye and an injured hand, and
had to be driven to the nearby Rudow hospital.
Nobody else tried for the "Höhenkurven-Preis". It was heavily
criticized in the aviation press after the meeting as being too
difficult and dangerous, and also irrelevant for practical flying.
The mayhem was still not over. At 18:12 Jeannin started, but before he
managed to take off a wheel hit a deep, overgrown hole in the ground.
The skid of his landing gear cut into the ground and steered the
machine into a barrier, where it nosed over and was badly damaged. Some
of the flyers had entered a second spare machine, but Engelhard and
Jeannin had only entered one. They did, however, get the necessary
consent from all other contestants and were allowed to use spare
machines during the rest of the meeting.
Sunday 15 May
The sixth day of the meeting was windy and started as the fifth had
finished: with a crash. This time the victim was Behrend, who within
one minute of the three o'clock starting time was first to go for
the "Frühpreis" in his Schultze-Herfort monoplane. He had
flown one lap when he noticed a quickly approaching thunderstorm and
decided to land at the end of the front straight. It was already too
late, since a gust took hold of his plane as he turned to taxi it back
to the hangars and flipped it. Once again luck was with the pilot, who
emerged unscathed. The machine wasn't very badly damaged, but it
was out for the rest of the meeting.
After that incident there was no activity until 16:47, when de Caters
made a flight of almost eleven minutes, but had to land on the back
straight before capturing the "Frühpreis". The prize was
instead won by Svendsen, who started four minutes later, before Thelen
and Frey.
Keidel's Wright was finally repaired. He took off at 17:02, but had
only flown for 16 minutes when disaster struck again. While flying low
along the back straight a gust forced the machine into the ground. The
nose dug in and the machine flipped. It was completely wrecked and even
briefly caught fire when the fuel tank broke. Keidel once again escaped
injuries.
This was the last day to compete for the landing prize and the gliding
prize, and both were won by de Caters before Jeannin. De Caters managed
to glide for 196 metres after cutting his engine below the prescribed
height of ten metres. Jeannin, on the other hand, had time to make a
40-minute flight that put him way out of reach in the totalization
prize. Frey made four passenger flights, the longest lasting 23:34,
winning him second in the passenger prize after Engelhard. Amerigo made
two passenger flights of three and five minutes and von Gorrissen made
a six-minute flight.
Monday 16 May
The last day of the meeting was Whit Monday, a public holiday. The
weather was sunny and the big crowds hoped to see many flights, but
despite the heat and sunshine it was still quite windy and there were
long periods without any action. De Caters, Thelen, Amerigo and von
Gorrissen all tried for the "Frühpreis" when it opened at
three o'clock, but gave up because of the high winds. Jeannin
started soon after, but after only a lap and a half he was forced down.
Once again he ran into hole and nosed over, so also his spare machine,
a French-built original Farman, was wrecked. He managed to abandon ship
at the last moment and escaped injury. It wasn't until more than
half an hour later that de Caters could win the "Frühpreis",
before Frey, and then the airfield was quiet for more than an hour.
At 17:09 Frey took off for the "smallest circle" prize. He
climbed immediately to 80 metres, flew a lap of the course and was just
about to start his circle when the machine was caught by a gust from
the north-east that drove it down towards the hangars at high speed. He
was saved from crashing into them by having the extra altitude margin
and the presence of mind to try to climb some extra metres when hit by
the gust, but he was blown far outside the airfield over Rudow. After
this very narrow escape there was no activity until 18:25, when de
Caters made two efforts for the "smallest circle" prize and
Frey one more. They reached 194 metres and 166 metres respectively, so
the contest was won by Jeannin, who had flew a circle of only 115
metres already on the Thursday, under much better circumstances. After
these last flights the meeting was concluded and the spectators,
probably not altogether pleased with the day's events, went home.
Conclusion
The German aviation press wasn't overwhelmed by the meeting. It had
of course been hit by wind and rain, but many were disappointed with
the quality of the events, which according to the Deutsche Zeitschrift
für Luftschiffahrt "fell considerably short of what one is
entitled to expect of such an event in the German capital". Part
of the reason was the shortage of prize money, but the bad condition of
the airfield, with lots of overgrown ruts and holes, was also heavily
criticized. The loss of machines through accidents of course also
contributed to the lack of action during the last days. As the many
accidents proved, any landing outside the dedicated starting area
involved a big risk and it was pointed out that pure luck was an
important reason that only one pilot was only relatively lightly
injured. It was reported that some pilots were considering suing the
organizers for damages and it was noted that even Jeannin, who won
almost half the prize money, couldn't by far cover the cost of his
damaged machines.