The world's first town-to-town aeroplane race
The front page of the official program of the meeting, showing the
Pont de la Basse-Chaîne, the spires of the Angers cathedral and, at
the right edge, one of the towers of the castle. (1)
Georges Legagneux arriving at the airfield. (2)
The main entrance of the airfield. (3)
Walter de Mumm posing in front of the Antoinette engine of one of
his two machines. The other was equipped with an ENV engine. (3)
Bertram Dickson posing by the Gnôme engine of his Farman. Note the
propeller mounted between the engine and the main bearing. (3)
Dickson's Farman after his crash on the Friday. The damages
only put him out of action for one day. (4)
Daniel Kinet busy assembling his plane, holding a tail skid in his
hand. He would survive less than six weeks after the Angers
meeting, succumbing on July 15th to injuries after a crash. (3)
Edmond Audemars' tiny Demoiselle - but neither of the two men
looks like Audemars. (3)
Jacques Balsan's two Blériots. Both carried race number 6, one
had a cockade on the rudder. In the background de Mumm flies by.
(5)
De Mumm's Antoinette after crashing into the trees. It took a
whole day to retrieve it. (6)
Émile Aubrun and his #7 Blériot. The engine is a two-cylinder
Clément-Bayard. (5)
Aubrun preparing for a flight. (3)
Marcel Paillette in front of his Sommer, which was equipped with an
extra tank below the centre section. (3)
Legagneux flashing a smile for the camera. (5)
The four machines lined up before the start of the Angers-Saumur
race. (5)
A spectator greeting Legagneux at his arrival at Breil. (7)
Dickson getting off the horse after being rescued from his wet
landing-spot. (6)
Legagneux and Martinet celebrating their successful flights. The
wine producers of Saumur were very irritated that Champagne Mumm
had been granted a monopoly of wine sales during the meeting. (6)
Angers is the capital of the department of Maine-et-Loire in western
France. It was a town already in Roman times and it was the capital of
the ancient province of Anjou, on the western border of France. It is
situated around 300 km southwest of Paris, on the river Maine, which is
one of the tributaries of the Loire. In 1910 the town had around 85,000
inhabitants, living from textile industry and trade in agricultural
produce and wine.
Like in several other towns in 1909 and 1910, the impulse to organize
an aviation meeting in Angers was partly due the cancellation of Grand
Prix automobile racing in 1909. The cancellation was caused by an
agreement between most of the major car manufacturers to boycott the
1909 season because of disagreements over regulations. One of the
cancelled races was the "Circuit d'Anjou".
In October 1909 a couple of Angers organisations raised the idea to
organize an aviation contest in 1910 instead. A committee was formed,
headed by René Gasnier (president) and Julien Bessonneau (secretary
general). The city council of Angers decided to contribute 25,000
francs, which enabled the planning to start. The military exercise
grounds in Avrillé, some three kilometres north of the city centre, was
selected as the best place to construct an airfield, and after some
discussions the military gave their permission. The meeting was
sanctioned by the Aéro-Club de France and in March 1910 a delegation
visited Angers to inspect the field. The committee also decided to
arrange the world's first cross-country aeroplane race, between
Angers and Saumur, a distance of around 43 kilometres.
The meeting attracted a field of nine pilots:
- Émile Aubrun, Blériot
- Jacques Balsan, Blériot
- André Crochon, Farman
- Bertram Dickson, Farman
- Daniel Kinet, Farman
- Georges Legagneux, Sommer
- Robert Martinet, Farman
- Walter de Mumm, Antoinette
- Marcel Paillette, Sommer
Dickson, Legagneux, Kinet and Balsan had participated in previous
meetings, but the rest of the field were newcomers. Paillette, son of a
brewer from Le Havre, didn't even have a licence - he planned to
qualify at the meeting. Martinet had only taken delivery of his Farman
on May 1st, but was already regarded as a rising star. He had only ten
days before the meeting made a cross-country flight of some 140
kilometres from Mourmelon to Neufmoutiers in an hour and a half, a
great achievement even though he had a good tailwind. Walter von Mumm
(known in France as "de Mumm") was a member of the wealthy
German Champagne-producing family and had done a lot of ballooning, but
had only recently learned to fly an aeroplane. Belgian Daniel Kinet had
made his debut at the Palermo meeting only one month earlier, but held
the world distance and endurance records with a passenger since
April.
Crochon dropped out at a very late stage, only days before the start of
the meeting. He was replaced by the Swiss Edmond Audemars, who planned
to make the public debut of the Demoiselle, the light monoplane
originally designed by Alberto Santos-Dumont and now license-built by
the Clément-Bayard company. Unfortunately Audemars was not allowed to
participate in the official flights. He had completed the qualification
flights for his pilot's license a couple of days before the
meeting, but the paperwork wasn't ready in time.
The first machine, Legagneux's Sommer, arrived on May 18th,
followed by Dickson's Farman and the first of de Mumm's two
Antoinettes the day after. Martinet had planned to fly his machine to
Angers, but the meeting committee refused on the grounds that it was
too close to the meeting and that they wanted to be sure that Martinet
and his plane arrived safely and could perform at the meeting. After a
three-day drive Martinet eventually arrived two days before the start
of the meeting, having had to buy two Grégoire cars in order to tow his
plane to the meeting!
Marcel Paillette on his Sommer was the first to make any flights on the
Angers-Avrillé airfield, on June 1st. Those flights were actually his
license qualification flights, observed by officials from the Aéro-Club
de France. He was allowed to participate in the meeting, so his
paperwork was apparently completed more quickly than Audemars'.
The day before the meeting the hangar area was open for visits, for a
price of one franc. This was followed by a luxurious inauguration
luncheon with speeches by René Gasnier and by the prefect of
Maine-et-Loire and the mayor of Angers, Dr. Monprofit. At the end of
the day Dickson made a successful test flight in front of the few
remaining visitors.
There were celebrations all around Angers. Concerts with civilian and
military orchestras and choirs were arranged every day during the
meeting. All public buildings were illuminated and the mayor asked the
people of the town to decorate their houses with flags during the
meeting.
Friday 3 June
The weather on the morning of the first day of the meeting was warm and
fairly calm, but some threatening clouds were already building up.
Already at ten o'clock many people had gathered outside the
airfield, but they had to wait until two o'clock before the gates
opened, so they had to spend their time in the numerous bars and cafés
arranged outside. The road from Angers to the airfield was a
single-lane slow-moving queue of automobiles and carriages of all
descriptions. Nothing happened at the airfield during the morning, only
a couple of engine tests. Around 14:15 it started to rain, but when the
rain stopped at 15:30 the red flag was hoisted in the signal mast.
Paillette was first in the air, at around 15:50, and flew several laps
before landing safely. He was followed by Legagneux, who took off at
16:05 for a two-lap flight, immediately followed by de Mumm, who flew
three laps. The next to start was Dickson, who immediately climbed to a
greater altitude and made a very controlled flight of 23 laps, winning
him the prize for the day's longest flight.
At five o'clock Martinet took off. After flying three laps at an
altitude of some fifteen metres he was caught by an "air
wave" and crashed. It was not very windy, but the air was quite
turbulent in a couple of places due to the trees and woods around the
airfields. Martinet was not injured and his machine was declared to be
easily repairable, the main damages being a broken propeller and
landing gear.
Around six o'clock the weather conditions improved and from then
until half past seven the flights succeeded each other. De Mumm made
three short flights, Legagneux two and Paillette one. The highest
flight of the day was made by Balsan, who reached almost 100 metres
during a flight of 15 kilometres, the day's second longest. But
there was also a second crash - this time it was Dickson, who flew into
the ground when turning too sharply: "I smashed my machine ...
doing some fancy turns and got caught in a bad remous". Again
damages were relatively minor and Dickson was unhurt.
Saturday 4 June
It started raining during the Friday evening, but it stopped during the
night. During the morning it was again warm with only light winds, but
a bit misty and cloudy. Already at half past eight Aubrun rolled out
his machine for the first time. He made four test flights during the
morning in order to ensure that his engine ran well. Daniel Kinet and
his Farman arrived during the morning and his mechanics immediately
started assembling it. At ten o'clock Legagneux flew two laps
before climbing to 80 metres and passing over the trees at the
northwest end of the airfield. He steered towards the village of
Avrillé, where he circled the church tower before returning to
land.
The grandstands were completely sold out and the cheap spectator areas
were also filling up. Some people contented themselves by watching from
the centre of Angers, where the signal mast and the observation tower
were visible in the far distance from the main square, Place du
Ralliement.
Legagneux started the afternoon's official flights by taking off at
half past two. After flying for half an hour he made a five-minute stop
to refuel, before taking off again. This time he remained longer in the
air, circling and circling the course while getting some change by
climbing to 125 metres for some laps, then flying first over the
grandstands and then over the Bois de la Perrière forest north of the
airfield. He landed after 58 laps to refuel one more time and took off
at 16:42, but landed again after only a few minutes. At 17:20 he took
off again and kept flying until he had completed a total of 110 laps of
the 1.666 km course!
Paillette also made a good performance, covering 54 laps during four
flights between 15:00 and 18:15. Aubrun completed some forty laps
during three flights between 15:30 and 18:35, reaching an altitude of
150 metres and repeating Legagneux's feat of rounding the church
tower of Avrillé. Balsan made two flights of in total 16 laps,
complaining about turbulence. De Mumm had to land before completing his
first lap, and Audemars flew a lap in pouring rain at 20:10, after the
end of the official flying.
Sunday 5 June
The weather was calm and sunny in the morning. From ten o'clock
until four in the afternoon the trams to the airport were completely
full and the queue of cars and carriages reached the city centre. It
was estimated that more than 50,000 people visited the airfield during
the day. Those who couldn't get there watched proceedings from the
Place du Ralliement and from the crowded roads outside the
airfield.
The first to make a flight in the morning, before the official flights
started at three o'clock, was de Mumm. He made a good take-off, but
soon after the start he hit some turbulence over the Bois de la
Perrière, lost control and crashed into the trees. De Mumm was not
injured, but his machine was badly damaged and it took his mechanics
and helpers all day to retrieve it, bit by bit, from the forest. At
13:45 Kinet rolled out his Farman for the first time and flew a lap.
When he had landed Audemars made a four-lap flight, followed only
minutes later by another flight of six laps, at a height of 15-20
metres.
When the cannon shot announced the start of official flights at three
o'clock Legagneux was immediately in the air, followed three
minutes later by Martinet and seven minutes later by Aubrun. The latter
flew only one lap around the course and then turned above the
grandstands, out of the airfield and circled Avrillé before landing to
receive the ovations of the enthusiastic crowd. Next in the air was
Paillette, who flew three laps as a prelude to a day of almost constant
flying, broken only by short stops to fill the tanks, but never flying
above 15-20 metres. At 15:40 Legagneux took off again and immediately
climbed high. His engine ran very well and he appeared to be in
complete and effortless control of his machine.
Around four o'clock Kinet took off, but a wheel buckled and pitched
his machine into a fence. The machine was quite badly damaged, but the
pilot escaped unharmed. At 16:05 Dickson took off in his repaired
machine, but his engine didn't run well and he landed after three
laps. He was followed by Martinet, who started a long and very regular
flight at a height of 20 metres. After a short stop Dickson took off
again, making it four planes around the short course. This inevitably
led to some traffic, and the worst affected was Paillette. He had to
take quick evasive action inside the course when Dickson came down over
him from above, but he managed the sharp turn without difficulty.
Dickson then climbed to the impressive altitude of 225-250 metres,
before landing at 17:48 after cutting his engine for one of the long
"vols planés" for which he was famous after the Tours
meeting. The crowd followed his steep descent in anguish and greeted
his safe landing with a "veritable explosion of bravos".
By that time Legagneux had completed 50 laps and Paillette 78, but
Martinet kept turning and turning around the airfield, finally landing
at 18:16 after covering 106 laps! Paillette landed and tried to take
off again, but fouled his landing gear in the vegetation and had to
stop. Legagneux suddenly took off at 18:54 and immediately climbed to
an altitude of 200 metres. To the applause of the crowds he climbed
even higher and turned southwards towards the centre of Angers. He
reached 550 metres and made a big turn over the town, returning to land
ten minutes later. The ecstatic crowd greeted him with by waved hats,
handkerchiefs and umbrellas before carrying him on their shoulders.
After telling about his flight between the castle and the cathedral
above the enthusiastic crowds in the flag-decorated streets and on the
Maine he was asked about his impressions. "Oh, c'est très
chic", he simply replied.
The longest flight of the day, almost 126 kilometres, was made by
Paillette, whose 195.55 km also won the day's total distance prize.
Legagneux still led the contest for the longest total distance of the
meeting with a margin of 36 kilometres, and he won the day's
altitude prize by reaching an officially measured 238 metres. The total
distance flown during the day was 609 kilometres.
The evening was celebrated by a concert and the aviators were invited
by the mayor to a "vin d'honneur" at the town hall,
together with dozens of VIPs and representatives of the press.
Monday 6 June
The weather again started calm, humid and very warm, but nobody made
any flights in the morning. At nine o'clock the flyers visited
Saumur by car to have a look at the landing field of the cross-country
race, before immediately returning to Angers in order to complete their
preparations. The landing airfield was the Prairie du Breil (apparently
often spelled "Bray" in those days), a cavalry exercise
ground on a peninsula bordered by the Loire and its tributary the
Thouet, around 2.5 kilometres northwest of the centre of Saumur.
During the morning an additional contest was announced: two prizes of
1,000 and 500 francs for the longest total distance flown with a
passenger. Around noon it started to rain rather heavily, but the
weather improved after a couple of hours and when it was time for the
official flights to start at three o'clock the red flag was
hoisted. Five minutes later Paillette took off, as usual flying low,
slow and safe. He was followed almost immediately by Dickson, who flew
lap after lap with one of his mechanics as passenger. At 15:15
Legagneux took off and flew 25 laps before leaving the airfield and
circling the church tower of Avrillé in order to "evaluate the
state of the atmosphere" before the cross-country race. At five
o'clock the cannon announced that flights at the airfield stopped
in preparation for the cross-country race. Paillette and Dickson had
flown 65 laps and Legagneux 64. Dickson's flight of 98.75
kilometres won him the prize for the longest passenger flight. De Mumm
made a short test flight of two laps in his reserve machine, but
didn't manage to gain any height.
It had been announced that Martinet, de Mumm, Legagneux and Dickson
would contest the Angers-Saumur race. The four pilots lined up their
machines on the field. The flyers were supposed to take off at
five-minute intervals. Conditions were again perfect, with almost no
wind. Martinet was first to start, at 17:20. He immediately climbed
high and left the airfield, visible for several minutes as a little dot
against the sky in the south-east. At 17:25 de Mumm tried to take off,
but he didn't manage to lift off despite rolling hundreds of meters
on the ground. He taxied back to the hangars and withdrew from the
race, disappointed and furious. At 17:30 Legagneux took off. He chose a
more easterly course than Martinet, but appeared to fly fast. He flew
lower than Martinet and soon disappeared from view. Dickson was next,
but the tail of his machine was damaged while manoeuvring on the
ground, "broken by some fools of workmen holding it just as I was
starting", according to the pilot. The repairs delayed his
take-off until 17:45, the loss of almost eleven minutes of course
putting him out of contention for the win. He took a more southerly
course and turned to the right over the town, probably in order to find
the Loire as quickly as possible.
Most of the spectators left the airfield immediately when the flyers
had left, but some stayed, since Legagneux had said he would fly back
after the race. Thousands of people followed the flights, in the
streets of Angers and all the towns and villages along the Loire, and
from roofs and chimneys. At six o'clock the first news of the
results were reported back to René Gasnier via the specially arranged
telephone lines.
None of the pilots had any incidents during the flight, which all made
at altitudes of 250 to 500 metres. The only exception was Legagneux,
who had a wire come loose during the flight and worried that it might
find its way into the propeller, but in the end nothing happened. There
were plenty of landmarks along the way to help navigation, from the
cathedral and the "Tour au Plomb", the lead factory tower, in
central Angers to the church towers of Saint-Léonard, Saint-Barthélemy
and Saint-Mathurin, and finally the Loire.
The Prairie du Breil was full of people, eagerly expecting the
aviators. The grandstands were sold out and the soldiers tasked with
keeping the airfield clear had a hard time. The municipality of Saumur
had organized several events in connection with the race, among them
several concerts, a gymnastic show and a football match between teams
from Saumur and Angers. Two balloons would fly from the airfield, there
would be a kite-flying contest and a flock of homing pigeons would be
released.
Martinet was first to arrive, at 17:51. He landed immediately after a
short glide and was greeted by the mayors of Saumur and the
neighbouring commune of Saint-Florent. Fifteen minutes later Legagneux
also passed the finish line. He didn't land at once, but flew
several turns over the town and the castle of Saumur before landing,
thus winning the 1,000 francs prize for the longest flight over the
airfield. A further fifteen minutes later Dickson finally arrived,
flying very high. He claimed that since head lost so much time on the
ground he "started for sport, rose to 3,000 feet en route and vol
planed down from 1,200 feet to astonish the natives". He happened
to land in a part of the field that was still wet after being flooded
only days before and had to be rescued on horseback from the foot-deep
water.
Martinet had won, his time of 31:35 beating Legagneux's 36:25 and
Dickson's 44:53. After the landings the crowds broke through the
fences in order to get a closer look at the aeroplanes and the pilots.
When Legagneux's mechanics arrived by car it was decided that he
wouldn't fly back after all. The remaining crowds at Avrillé
received the message at half past eight and had to leave disappointed,
and Legagneux eventually returned to Angers by car at 22:15. All the
machines were dismantled at Saumur and removed by road.
Conclusion
Martinet and Paillette made some short flights on the Tuesday, but
otherwise the flyers quickly disassembled and packed their planes.
Audemars rushed to the Port-Aviation meeting, which started already the
following weekend. Paillette and Dickson travelled to the Rouen
meeting, which started less than two weeks later, where they would once
again meet the busy Audemars. As usual, work immediately started on
dismantling and removing the temporary airfield installations. The
timber used for all the fences around the airfield had been announced
for sale in the local newspapers already before the meeting
started!
The meeting had been a complete success, bringing lots of business and
visitors to the town. The railway and tram lines had transported almost
50,000 people to the meeting and when the financial results had been
calculated it was announced that the sponsors would get almost all
their money back. The weather hadn't caused any major troubles and
flyers had completed a total distance of 1,398.795 kilometres with no
major accident.
The fact that the Angers-Saumur race was the first of its kind was of
course noted in the aviation press of the time, but didn't really
make headline news. The press was full of spectacular flying exploits
every week, for example Charles Rolls' double crossing of the
English Channel, which happened around the same time, and the start of
the Budapest meeting, with the biggest prize fund of the season.